Want to make some people mad? Tell them that brainstorming is a lousy way to generate ideas. That's what I did, and boy, did I hit a nerve!
I conducted a workshop for nonprofit communicators on how to generate and harness the power of their ideas. The 15 main points of my workshop appear below. There was a surprising amount of vocal dissent and resistance to two of my points, numbered 8 and 9 below. These two pertain to my notion that brainstorming is ineffective, and that most good ideas come from one or two people instead of a large group.
Evidently my lone-wolf approach to idea-generation is not universal, and my criticism of the brainstorming process really touched a raw nerve with some attendees, who were not shy about telling me how wrong I was. The ensuing discussion was insightful, though. The consensus view of the discussion is that brainstorming is not a bad thing in and of itself, but that most teams don't implement it well.
One nonprofit CEO in the session said he does use groups and teams for idea generation, but with a twist that I liked very much. Instead of brainstorming, where the premise is that "we won't judge the ideas, there are no bad ideas, etc.," he creates an agenda and tells people to come to the meeting with one or two specific ideas that will solve the problem or address the issue at hand. That seems like an excellent way to use team resources. People actually have to think deliberately about the situation, and come to the meeting to present a legitimate idea. Because they "own" the idea (unlike in a traditional brainstorming process), they are more likely to come up with good ones.
Another participant shared a good approach as well. Like me, he tends to generate ideas solo, but then he shares it with someone who does not think like he does -- someone likely to have an opposing viewpoint or a "Devil's Advocate" response. I like that. I tend to test my ideas on my colleagues, who are willing to disagree, but who view the world largely the same way I do. In the future, I will seek out people whose opinions I respect, but who do not think the same way I do.
What do you think about brainstorming? Send me an e-mail and I'll share your ideas with others:
info@highviewhelp.com.
The 15 points from my workshop appear below my signature block.
Regards,
Steve
Cebalt, Author
The Communications Handbook for Nonprofits and Foundations
Here are the 15 idea-generating points that I included in the workshop:
1. Idea generation is a process – more like science or engineering than many people might think. It is not an innate skill or an inherent “creativity gene.” Idea generation is a skill like any other; it can be taught, and learned. But many people dismiss their own creative powers. “I’m just not creative.” Bull. Everyone can learn to be more creative. But it takes work. Not much, but some. But once you label yourself as “not creative,” guess what – you’ll never be creative. You’ll have to stoop to calling your intellectually inferior Dad for ideas, and none of us wants that. …
2. The most important part of the process is to capture and save every idea you have. That’s where my daughter and others like her go awry. We all get dozens of ideas every day. But some people don’t recognize them as valuable assets and capture them. I maintain an extensive archive of ideas in a simple word document. If I see something in the paper that might make a good science project for one of my kids, I log it on my idea bank in my computer, even if the science fair is a year away. When one of the kids starts scrambling for an idea, I’
ve got one (usually several) captured in my idea bank that I snagged just from reading the paper, watching TV, etc. If I get a great direct-mail piece in the mail with a clever headline, I save in an “inspiration” folder.
3. Keep a notepad and pen with you always. If you have an idea, you have to capture it, because you may not get it back! So whether you are out mowing the lawn, watching a kid’s soccer game, or shopping at the grocery, be sure you have a notepad and pen handy. Keep notepads by your bed, in your car, in your pockets/purse, and all over the house. Collect those ideas on some sort of list, and throw the papers away.
4. Let it go. Don’t struggle for ideas. Ideas that you struggle for are usually bad. I read that Paul McCartney wrote “Yesterday” without any effort; he had the tune in his head, and in fact he thought he’d heard it on the radio. He played it on the piano and John Lennon said “What was THAT!” The best ideas just come naturally. That’s why we often get great ideas in the shower – because we are not TRYING – our mind is free to roam, and that opens up space for ideas to pop in. So don’t force it; if you can’t come up with the idea right now, let it simmer until inspiration strikes. It will! That’s why the notepad habit is so crucial. Now, if you can figure out how to keep a notepad in the shower, please e-mail me! That would be a breakthrough.
5. I keep a hand-held recorder in my car. When I hit the road for an out of-town meeting, my mind tends to really run with ideas – again, because I am not trying to force it; they just come. So I record them and capture them that way, safely, while driving. This is especially effective on your way home from a meeting, when you want to capture all the things you discussed that may need follow-ups.
6. Use quotes. Read quote books. This may seem like a lazy approach or “cheating” to rely on a famous quotation, but it almost never fails. For example:
"Ideas are like rabbits. You get a couple, learn how to handle them, and pretty soon you have a dozen. " -- John Steinbeck.
7. You don’t have to have a great idea. A mediocre one will do, to get you started. As you progress with your project, more ideas will emerge. Don’t wait for the perfect idea – start with ANY decent idea and get going.
8. Brainstorming is a ridiculous practice. I’
ve never seen a good idea emerge from a brainstorming session, because the process is not intentional; the basic premise is that “there are no bad ideas.” The fact is that MOST ideas are bad, and that’s what you get from freewheeling brainstorming sessions. Bad ideas. Can you imagine Picasso or Mozart in a brainstorming session? Me neither.
9. Most great ideas will come from just one person working alone. At some point, it can be helpful to air your thoughts with a colleague, to formulate abstract concepts into concrete ideas.
10. Recycle your ideas. A great idea that worked once will work again. No need to reinvent the wheel!
11. Copy ideas from others and add your own twist.
12. Write an ad. Often, when I am working on a new project, the first thing I do is create an ad for the program, service or project. This forces me to think logically, i.e. “Who is that target audience? What do I want them to do? What do they need to know in order to do that? How can I express that most effectively?” These ads are just exercises, not for publication; but they allow me to organize my thinking and produce good ideas.
13. This one’s important. After you have a killer idea, set it aside. Force yourself to come up with two more – two completely different approaches. While our impulse is to believe that our first idea is the best, in fact your second or third effort is often superior.
14. If you can’t come up with an idea right now, write down on your to-do-list, “Revisit the
XYZ problem and generate ideas.” This establishes the task so you don’t forget that you need to generate the idea. Often, as you go about your business in the coming days, you’ll stumble across something in a magazine article or on TV that will inspire you, but the seed has to be planted!
15. Never conclude a professional discussion without asking, “What have we produced a result of this discussion?” Many times we have informal or formal meetings that are inconclusive. The point is to identify what WAS accomplished and the next step, every time. If you have not accomplished ANYTHING, then you just wasted valuable time and energy. Usually, the discussion has accomplished SOMETHING, though -- so take a moment to determine what the product of your conversation was. This is the difference between idle chit-chat and capturing great ideas. Example: “Discussed website overhaul; considered offering credit card payment option and redesigning the home page. Revisit next week and decide action steps.”
I’ll wrap up with another quote, from Andy Rooney of “60 Minutes”:
“If I have an idea, I sit down and start typing. If I don’t have an idea, I sit down and decide to have one.”
That’s more profound that it sounds. ….Deciding to have an idea is the essence of the entire process. Deciding to have an idea means committing to coming up with something. It means recognizing your own innate creative potential, with confidence. Columnists on deadlines know all about this. "I have decided to have and idea" is an affirmative statement that removes all excuses and it eliminates writer’s block. Once you make that commitment to yourself, the 15 steps above should help you achieve your goal, without calling your Dad for help.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Get My Blog Updates via the Convenience of E-mail!
Just use the “Get My Updates” e-mail function, which you’ll find on the top right-hand corner of this blog, right above the picture of the handsome bald guy. ...